PayPal
BitCoin
Facebook
Twitter
Amazon
RSS
iTunes

DoseNation Podcast

Weekly news, talk, and interviews. More »

SUGGEST A STORY  |   CREATE AN ACCOUNT  |  
DoseNation.com

Review: 'The Holy Mushroom' by Jan Irvin

Originally published in 2008 "The Holy Mushroom: Evidence of Mushrooms in Judeo-Christianity" by Jan R. Irvin, with Jack Herer, is a fine addition to a very much under-researched area; the entheogenic relationship with religion. It critically re-evaluates the schism between the theory's two greatest proponents -- R. Gordon Wasson and John M. Allegro -- and introduces new pictorial and textual evidence to add weight to the contemporary arguments.

The study of entheobotany developed off the back of ethnobotany, which is to say the relationship between humans and plants developed into the more precise consideration of the theoretical existence of a connection between hallucinogenic agents and religious/spiritual practice in human history.

There's a fair amount of controversy surrounding the topic and this is reflected in the fact that, for the most part, mainstream researchers have failed to give it a detailed deconstruction; leaving it beyond even the periphery of academic circles. However, one deconstruction that has been performed was by Dr. Andy Letcher in his book "Shroom". He concluded that, according to the available evidence, the religious use of magic mushrooms in the Western world is a modern phenomena. According to Irvin, however, "The Holy Mushroom" disproves his conclusion.

Posted By psypressuk at 2010-05-28 11:54:36 permalink | comments
Facebook it! Twitter it! Digg it! Reddit! StumbleUpon It! Google Bookmark del.icio.us technorati Furl Yahoo! Bookmark
» More ways to bookmark this page


Cliff Burns. : 2010-06-03 11:48:53
To quote to great Bill Hicks:

[link]

soma_junkie. : 2010-05-31 06:58:28
@Jedi....I think the Kykeon had to be some type of ergotized grain and Soma was usually Amanita Muscaria but was sometimes whatever was on hand....anything from Syrian Rue to Datura. I've never heard of what you mention of the Russian Olive Tree...I'll have to look it up.
Jedi Mind Traveler : 2010-05-29 13:48:50
Hey Soma Junkie, any thoughts on what exactly was the Soma of the Rig Veda or the Kykeon of the Elusinian Mysteries? It seems like if Kykeon was ergotized rye, with maybe a mint family leaf, then people today should be able to reproduce it, but to my knowledge no one has. Also, I tend to think Soma was a combination of things, including the Amanita - the whole thing about worshiping cows seems to point to the psilocybes growing from the dung. One interesting possibility is the use of the Russian Olive Tree leaves as an MAOI, with some DMT containing species. Also, has anyone tried to grow amanita in grape juice to produce a strong amanita wine? This could have been used by Jesus and early Christians, as well as the wafer being a amanita mycelium grown on barley. This book has many bible references to wine suggesting amanita: [link]
soma junkie. : 2010-05-28 23:50:38
I'll have to give it a read. So far I haven't seen any really good evidence so far of these sorts of claims of early Christianity/Judaism, only later Christianity claims have good evidence as Jedi Mind Traveller mentions, though even that would have to be categorized as being unorthodox in nature.

If anything, Christianity has elements of psychedelic-type ideas in it only because it was a Jewish descendant of the Greek Mystery Religion traditions (see: The Jesus Mysteries by Timothy Freke and Peter Gandy.) (Don't see: Shroom by Andy Letcher...that book is awful.)

As far as Judaism goes....the best argument for psychedelics being involved with that religion is that the Burning Bush in Exodus was an Acacia bush (which contains DMT) and the Ark of the Covenant was built completely from Acacia wood as well. Syrian rue is native to the region and I'm pretty sure the Egyptian High Priests (of which Moses was probably one) would have known how to use these.

guest : 2010-05-28 20:36:41
I tend to think that some monks, at some time, may have used mushrooms, found that helped them get closer to God. But to make mushrooms the foundation of religions...that's going a bit far.
Jedi Mind Traveler. : 2010-05-28 17:48:30
I've read it. The evidence in frescoes from the 9th to 14th centuries all across Europe is pretty compelling. I find it interesting to consider Jesus as either someone deeply transformed by the mushroom (psilocybe especially) or simply the mushroom itself. In the Gospel of Thomas he tends to speak from the first person perspective of God, or as if he is someone on mushrooms.

Consider saying 17: I will give you that which eyes have not seen, ears have not heard, hands did not touch, and minds have not conceived.

In other words, eat my body (shrooms) and you will see the world before your conceptual mind gets a hold of it and collapses it. You will see the formless flow behind the solid form.

Or 19c: In paradise there are five trees that do not change between summer and winter and their leaves never fall. Anyone who comes to know them will not die.

Or, take enough entheogens and realize that awareness, consciousness never dies.

dreamdust. : 2010-05-28 15:52:30
I'll have to give it a read. Honestly, I don't give the theory much credit anymore. Just like McKenna, researchers trying to establish a link between religion and magic mushrooms seem to go out of their way to find evidence to support their theory while glossing over evidence that contradicts it.

The comments posted here do not reflect the views of the owners of this site.

HOME
COMMENTS
NEWS
ARCHIVE
EDITORS
REVIEW POLICY
SUGGEST A STORY
CREATE AN ACCOUNT
RSS | TWITTER | FACEBOOK
DIGG | REDDIT | SHARE