Inhalants on the rise? Uh, no
 | Slate's Jack Shafer takes a look at a recent Today show story about how the youth of today are apparently getting ripped on inhalants - now, more than ever before! Shafer's a reliable critic of this kind of media sensationalism, and he's more disgusted than usual by this one.
In the annals of stupid drug reporting, a special commendation must be reserved for NBC's Today show, which on Nov. 19 aired (video) one of the stupidest drug stories in broadcast news....
I could go on and on about the awfulness of the Today segment. I could write an angry paragraph about the hackery of playing "sad" music on the soundtrack as its reporter narrates the story of a 14-year-old who killed himself by inhaling Dust-Off. I could rail about the absence of any numbers to prove its assertion that huffing is a deadly trend. (It would be useful to know if more or fewer kids are killing or damaging themselves with inhalants than in previous years.) I could gripe about Today's failure to distinguish among the different kinds of inhalants (volatile solvents, aerosols, gases, nitrites, etc.) and the absence of any discussion of the nonlethal health dangers posed by the compounds. And I could close with a complaint about its hidden camera "gotcha," in which two child actors were video recorded buying inhalants in New York City stores.
» More ways to bookmark this page
|
Recently @ DoseNation
|
|
It really seems to me that Shafer dramatically overreacted to this story -- as he has done to drug-related stories in the past. While the "Today" report did contain some relatively minor inaccuracies, I see no harm in alerting parents to the possibility of inhalant abuse, while also putting retail stores on notice that blindly selling huffable products to kids might not be such a good idea.
The comments posted here do not reflect the views of the owners of this site.