In an online discussion, the question recently came up of what does "crazy" mean. I would say someone is crazy if and only if their mental processes appear to be causing their lives to be unsustainable, physical harm, organizational problems such as homelessness, self-destructive behavior, etc.
There are some times when I would call people crazy even when I think they're right. Like Robert M. Pirsig, author of
Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. Having read the book, I believe that he experienced a true and accurate spiritual insight, but was unable to deal with it in a way that didn't fuck up his life, and so he went crazy, and then slowly eventually put his shit back together. The book is a detailed narrative of that process and is so far beyond merely worth reading that I can't possibly recommend it highly enough. Don't be fooled by the title, it's more about what I said here than it is about Zen.
If your beliefs aren't fucking up your life (or anyone else's for that matter), then I don't see why it would make sense to call you crazy, no matter what you believe or experience.
I once knew someone who had hallucinations all the time. Never did any drugs, apparently she just had part of a clinically schizophrenic brain without a lot of the problems. She was very mellow, and smart, and was able to figure out what was real and what was hallucinated just fine. I would not call her crazy.
There was also this guy who put out a bunch of full-page spreads in The Stranger in Seattle about how he was the homosexual messiah and God wants all men to get over their homophobia and suck His holy Dick. He was rich, he went to Burning Man and did a bunch of drugs, and got on the I Am The Messiah trip that we all know all about because anyone who has even the remedial loser GED version of a drug education knows all about that. I'd call him crazy, temporarily at least, because even though being rich was insulating him from the consequences he'd probably go down the toilet eventually, if he didn't get his mind back under control. But that is just a guesstimation-prediction based on my broader experience, so I wouldn't
commit to saying he was crazy until he really did get messed up.
By the way, if anyone can remember that guy's web site, please add the link to this listing! :)
Does the same not happen with drugs, "oh, MDMA'll make you an emotionless robot," "LSD'll make you go nuts, batso," on and on, but such statements tend to come from those who only care to see that which is harmful, and use such to de-legitimize said actions.
Is cigarette smoking insane because it may lead to lung cancer and poorer physical performance? What about polluting the air we breath and the water from which we drink, for whatever reason? Oof, that all came out probably more rant'ish than I wanted it to. Definitely not meant as an attack.
The comments posted here do not reflect the views of the owners of this site.